Being Duncan – Now and in English
- Melanie Kerr
- Oct 22, 2023
- 3 min read
‘Duncan who?’ I hear you ask. Duncan Ban MacIntyre, a Gaelic poet of the 18th century, maybe even THE Gaelic poet of the 18th Century. I did a presentation on his life the other day. The presentation was minus the PowerPoint as the technology of uploading it to a shared screen on a media platform defeated me. I’m still living in feet and inches and pounds and ounces.
You all know Robert Burns, right? Burn’s Night and haggis and the ‘wee, sleekit, cowran, tim’rous beastie? MacIntyre was his contemporary. Where Burns lived in the south and wrote poems in Scots and enjoyed fame, fortune and the affection of the lasses, MacIntyre was a Highland poet, setting his lyrics to music and enjoying a more outdoor life of mountains, rivers and deer.
Duncan lived through the Battle of Culloden simply because he didn’t fight in it. He fought in the Battle of, no not Dunkirk as I was about to write, but Falkirk. He was paid to take the place of someone who didn't want to fight. A man called Fletcher, who gave him a sword and pushed him towards the battlefield. They were routed by the Jacobites and MacIntyre dropped his sword as he made his escape. The sword was not one of those named swords. No vorpal sword, no Valarian blade and no Sword of Gryffindor, it was just a sword, not sharp, not polished to a shine and just a tad chipped.
Enough with the lecture, Mel. We’ve done it once. What you need to know is that he was a poet, A Gaelic poet.
Incidentally, before I move on, I received a wonderful invitation from a friend this morning. We’re becoming friends, rather than actual friends. She knows I am partial to a poem. Her husband owned shelves of poetry books and she invited me round to her house to browse. How wonderful is that?
Back to Duncan. After the Battle of Culloden, the government implemented a reign of repression. They wanted to grind the defeated army into the bracken making it a crime to celebrate anything to do with highland life – no tartan, no kilts and no bagpipes. MacIntyre composed his ‘Song of the Breeches’ to complain about wearing trousers. They just didn’t feel comfortable – I know how he felt. There are lines in the song about the current crop of royalty having no right to rule. There is something incredibly powerful about a protest poem.
Here's one of mine…I think. It is a protest against division and our refusal to make the first step toward reconciliation.
Reconciliation
the tear in the fabric
of you and me
will get wider with the watching and
truth to tell
it will not mend itself
let us find the needle and thread
and make repairs
while the rent is small
before the ocean unfolds
we must not wait for the other
to make to first move
A lot of Duncan’s poetry is about daily life. He watched. He observed. He sang songs about ploughing fields and churning butter. His poetry rates as history in that it describes what every day life was like. He wasn’t a poet laureate who saved his best poems for the big events. It was the little things, the asides, the unremarkable things he commented on.
Here’s one of mine…just an ordinary task made extraordinary because I noticed and wrote about it.
If a man can mow
A neighbour’s lawn in the dark
Nothing holds him back

What MacIntyre is best known for is his nature poetry. He lived next to Ben Dorain near Glen Orchy. It was a mountain full of wildlife. He accepted hunting as a necessary part of life, with deer on the menu to feed the body. He also saw nature as a place of wellbeing with mountain air, exercise and an appreciation of the beauty of nature there to feed the soul.
Here’s one of mine…nature speaking a necessary message.
Salmon
I have mastered the oceans
Subdued the shifting sea
Flick-finned with the leviathan
Slip-scaled with serpents
Twist-tailed with mermaids
Small, I have out swam the great
Nimble, I have sidestepped the shark
Quick, I have left the school behind
Cautious, I have exploited the hiding places
I have weathered the storms
Felt the bite of lightning and
Heard the growl of thunder
Never tried to count the stars
Felt alone
Now I’m
Driven by an ache I cannot soothe
There’s a yearning inside
Compelled
I must go home
Oh, what hurdles!
Water that tumbles through rocks
Falling, falling, falling
That I must climb
Marshalling all that I have
Leaping, or falling short of the jump
Always the current against me
Nature rages, my enemy
But I don’t surrender
Crafted into every cell is
My life’s beginning
And its completion
I am home…
Poetry says it all. It speaks to the heart. You just have to listen.
Comments